Whether you’ve received notice of a complaint from your state’s professional board or been served with a lawsuit, one of the first questions is how to tell your side of the story while protecting yourself.

Often, your attorney will ask you to write a narrative or sign an affidavit. They may look alike, but they do very different jobs, and both can be secret weapons in building your defense.

The narrative: your story, in detail. A narrative gives your attorney the full picture: what you remember about the treatment, why you made the clinical decisions you did, and what you discussed with the patient. That matters most when the complaint questions the standard of care, informed consent, or the accuracy of your records. It also lets your attorney spot any gaps between your memory and the chart before anything goes to the board.

The affidavit: your story, under oath. An affidavit is a sworn statement of facts. It can stand in for in-person testimony, though the board may still require you to appear. Because you are swearing to its truth, every word has to be accurate and line up with the records. Not every board inquiry calls for one. It depends on the allegations and where the investigation stands.

Here’s the upside: this is your chance to have your story told your way. Don’t let your attorney’s phrasing or a stiff template speak for you. Read it closely, and make sure it sounds like you. If it doesn’t, say so. You have to be comfortable with your counsel, and that means you’re allowed to push back. It’s your license on the line.

Working with insurance-appointed counsel? That doesn’t mean you’re on your own. Insurance-appointed attorneys are often juggling heavy caseloads, and you may want someone in your corner focused solely on you. We can step in and assist alongside your appointed counsel. Better yet, call us first, before anything is drafted or signed.

And don’t panic if you’re asked to write one. A narrative or affidavit isn’t automatically headed to the board. Your attorney may simply need your perspective to evaluate the allegations, find defenses, and prep you for an investigative interview or hearing. Which is exactly why you should never send a written statement to an investigator or board without talking to counsel first.

The bottom line? Responding to a board inquiry or your perspective in a litigation defense is about more than recounting what happened. A careful review of the records, a well-prepared account in your own words, and the right type of response can sometimes quash problems early and helps keeping inconsistencies from undermining your defense. 

    For assistance or with any questions of your own, email me to connect (Jennifer@kirschenbaumesq.com).