Question:
Hi Jennifer,
Can an insurance company terminate my participation? We are having a real back and forth with a large payor of ours pushing back on a key diagnostic test. Lots of denials and appeals flowing.
Thanks,
Dr. U
Answer:
Often, yes. Many provider agreements permit either party to terminate the relationship without cause. The carrier may not be required to establish fraud, misconduct or a contractual breach.
Network participation is a contractual relationship—not a permanent entitlement. Do not assume fighting with the carrier over denied claims is limited to the claims department.
One theory we have on certain terminations - we regularly see practices respond to denials by submitting the same claims again—and again—with little or no change. The practice may believe it is appropriately pursuing payment. The carrier may view the pattern differently.
Repeated submissions, unresolved coding disputes and escalating payment demands can attract unwanted attention. What begins as a claims problem may become an audit, a request for records or a network participation issue.
Make sure your billing company is not simply hitting “resubmit” indefinitely.
Don't wait. Pick up the phone to the carrier. Ask for an "Education call" to see where the disconnect in the billing cycle is. Treat the carrier as a payor partner.
The objective is to address the underlying issue before the carrier decides it would be easier to terminate the relationship. If you need assistance at this stage, call us. Counsel can help effectuate.
Also, IMPORTANT, if you receive a termination notice, do not assume the decision is final.
The participation agreement (and termination notice) will contain options (legally required), including:
- Appeal or reconsideration rights;
- Notice requirements;
- Deadlines to respond;
- Opportunities to correct identified issues; or
- Procedures for challenging the termination.
The agreement and termination notice should be reviewed immediately by counsel. Missing a deadline may eliminate options that otherwise existed.
Unlike other responses you may see on this forum, in this instance, our planned strategy may not necessarily be an aggressive / combative one. Carriers often have broad discretion over network participation. Privilege, not a right. A hostile response may be satisfying to you, but it may not be effective for reinstatement.
Depending on the circumstances, the better strategy may be to demonstrate the value you bring to your patients and the community.
Bottom line: Be mindful if you are receiving recurring denials. Supervise your billing people. Escalate persistent issues before they become larger contractual problems.
Once the termination notice arrives, you are responding on the carrier’s timetable.
Pick up the phone before termination, or, at a minimum, immediately on termination. Waiting in either scenario may prove too late and fatal to participation.
