Question:
Hi Jennifer,
Is a New York employee entitled to their personnel record? If so, when, and what are they entitled to?
Thanks,
Dr. K
Answer:
Yes, and, new answers - starting November 8, 2026. Historically, New York treated an employee’s personnel file as the employer’s property, and employees had no right to see it. That changed this past September, when Governor Hochul signed Senate Bill S4360. The law requires employers to give current and former employees access to their personnel records. See: https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/bills/2025/S3460.
When? An employee who asks for their personnel record must get a copy within 5 days of the request, at no cost. Employers may limit reviews to 2 per year, but a review prompted by notice of negative documentation does not count toward that limit. Employers must also tell an employee within 10 days after placing a disciplinary record, or any other information that negatively affects the employee’s qualifications for employment, promotion, transfer, or additional compensation, in the employee’s file.
What? A “personnel record” is any record the employer maintains that identifies the employee and that has been used, or is used, in relation to the employee’s qualifications for employment, promotion, transfer, additional compensation, or disciplinary action. It includes:
• Employee name, address, date of birth, job title, and job description;
• Rate of pay and any other compensation paid to the employee;
• Starting date of employment;
• Job applications, resumes, and other forms of employment inquiry submitted to the employer;
• All performance or employee evaluation documents; and
• Lists of probationary periods, signed waivers, disciplinary actions, and termination notices.
Employees can also push back. If an employee disagrees with something in the file, the employer and employee can agree to remove or correct it. If they cannot agree, the employee may submit a written statement explaining their position. That statement becomes part of the personnel record and must accompany any disclosure of the disputed information. Employers must keep personnel records from the date of hire until 3 years after termination. The Attorney General enforces the law, and violations carry penalties of $500 to $2,500.
When she signed the law, Governor Hochul said a 2027 amendment would clarify that employers are not required to create or produce files they do not already maintain, and would narrow the definition of covered records. Until that amendment is passed, employers must comply with the law as it is written today.
What I recommend employers do now:
- Audit your current personnel records. What are your recordkeeping processes, and are people following them? Where are your files stored, physically or digitally? Who maintains them? Are they kept up to date?
- Revise your policies. Review your employee handbook and any personnel record policies, and update them or adopt new ones that address these access rights and employer obligations.
- Train your team. Work with your HR department or outside HR vendors so that the people handling requests are trained and have procedures in place to meet the 5-day and 10-day deadlines.
Above all, document everything. Keep written records of every performance, compensation, and disciplinary action involving an employee, because memories of those events get vague over time. Detailed files help you comply with the law and track employee performance properly. Don’t wait for a records request or an employment dispute to get your personnel files in order. Need help training / setting documentation? We’re here to help.
