I'm writing this on Monday.  Both of these examples happened today.  

The first, a client used AI to put together a beautiful, amazing, color coordinated employment term sheet for a candidate he is very excited about.  Bells and whistles galore are sprinkled through.  

The second, different client used AI to work through a draft employment agreement and chose to incorporate a gazillion legal concepts at every turn.   Language about overtime, different paid leaves, indemnity from every source... 

OK, so what’s the problem?   It sounds like in the first instance, a polished product was created.  It was polished, and it was released to the employee.  After the fact, it was sent to my attention. When I started going through the term sheet with my client, I had a number of questions.  Asking, "it seems here you intend to give the employee equity...Equity in what?  Equity in a management company?   I don’t recall setting up a management company.   Oh, you don’t have a management company!    Do you intend on creating a management company?   By the time this offer is to go into effect?   What about the extra piece about a Surgery Center?   Is that ownership component available for sale?"   I received a number of confused responses.  The intention was good.   The product was pretty.  But in reality, a number of the offer components that AI had thrown in as positives that an employee would love to see are not actually available and we’re not properly conditioned in the offer.   Now, unfortunately, my client has to recast the conversation with the recipient to clarify when, and how, and if, these potential opportunities will actually come into play.

Let’s turn to the second example where AI "Thought", wait... that’s not right, AI doesn’t think.  AI processed, after being prompted, inclusion of excessive legal protections and structures for employees, including very detailed language on exemptions, sick and paid leave ,workers compensation maternity, leave benefits, you name it, was in this draft.   Under no circumstance, will this office, myself included, ever give you advice, that as an employer, you should limit an employees rights to what they are entitled to under law.  However, that said, to the extent that there is no specific law, rule or regulation that you are required to highlight information or educate your employees on how they can manipulate the system, as your counsel, representing you, the employer, it is not my job to weaponize laws against you on behalf of your employees.  Big difference.  

So, yes, I have a bone to pick with AI, or SI, whatever we are calling Grok these days. Just like any other tool, we have to be careful in the person wielding it.   And I understand this is coming off as a reprimand, but that’s sort of my job. 

How to avoid both scenarios?   Well, the simple answer is, you need to run legal documents, i.e., a term sheet or an employment agreement by counsel.  Even better, rely on counsel to draft it.